If you are looking for a super fun and easy treat, this Cookie Monster Fudge Recipe is going to be a hit! It’s so much fun to make, and of course, your kids will love the bright blue colors! Whether you are serving this up for a Sesame Street themed birthday party or just because it will come together in minutes and become an often made favorite sweet treat.
Cookie Monster Fudge Recipe
This is a traditional fudge recipe that includes just a few extra ingredients to make it fun and colorful. We prefer using the Wilton brand of candy melts to make sure it turns out perfectly, but you can use any brand as long as they are the right amount and color. For this recipe, we used the royal blue Wilton candy melts.
Ingredients for Cookie Monster Fudge Recipe:
- 12oz blue Wilton candy melts
- 14oz can sweetened condensed milk
- 9 Chips Ahoy Cookies
- 9 Oreo Cookies
Supplies for Cookie Monster Fudge Recipe:
Directions for Cookie Monster Fudge Recipe:
- Line a baking pan with aluminum foil and spray with a non-stick cooking spray.
- Add your candy melts and sweetened condensed milk to your pot and heat on low, stirring every minute until melted.
- Crumble your cookies into your melted chocolate mixture and mix.
- Pour your melted chocolate mixture into your lined baking pan and let cool at room temperature for 30 minutes bed transferring to the fridge for about 3 hours.
- Slice and enjoy!
How to Store Fudge:
We usually don’t have much left once the kids get into this, but if you do have extra, make sure to keep it in a good airtight container, so it stays fresh. I prefer refrigerating fudge to keep it from melting if it gets warm in the kitchen, but you may prefer it a bit softer and keep it a container on the counter. The baking pans we use have great lids, so they are simple to just snap on top once done. You can also gift this cookie monster fudge recipe in cellophane bags or small treat tins!
More Delicious Dessert Recipes
We love dessert, so obviously we have some great recipes for you to try out! Aside from the above cookie monster fudge recipe, make sure to check out our favorites like the Unicorn Food Oreo Cookie Parfait Recipe, Popcorn S’Mores Brownies, or even our Chocolate Twinkie Sushi on our sister site A Worthey Read.